What Can You Put on Chalk Art to Make It Permanent

How well does Mod Podge piece of work with ink pads, pens, pencils, and markers? Which cause smearing when applied over/under? Find out hither!

If I had a penny for every time I've been asked a certain question about Mod Podge, I'd exist a millionaire. If you're wondering what that question is, here it is:

"Which ink pad/pens/pencils/markers tin I use with Modern Podge – with no smearing?"

Information technology'due south not asked exactly that way every unmarried time (that would exist amazing), merely it's pretty shut. I got embarrassed for awhile when I did get asked, considering I couldn't recall the answer. It was difficult to go along direct.

"Await," I'd say to myself, "does that ink pad work on top of Modern Podge or below it . . . or both?" Plus I'yard getting older and who tin can keep track of all that?! It made the most sense to do this experiment and write it all down in a post, which is what I'chiliad doing here.

And then what did I exam? 2 things:

1. if a product smeared when Mod Podge was applied over the top of it
2. if a product smeared when applied to the top of dried Modern Podge

And here's what I tested:

• Artist pens
• Ballpoint pen
• Chalk
• Chalk pencils
• Charcoal sticks
• Colored pencils
• Crayons
• Gel pens
• Ink pads – CraftSmart, Colorbox, Encore!, Memento Luxe, Ranger Archival Ink, StazOn, Tim Holtz Distress Ink
• Atomic number 82 pencil
• Markers – Copic, Crayola, Liquitex paint, Prismacolor Premier, Sharpie regular, Sharpie oil based, Rust-o-leum stain, Tombow waterbased castor pens
• Oil pastels
• Watercolor pencils

Here are the results. And you lot demand to read carefully. Non considering I don't call up you can read, but because I desire to make sure you fully empathize the results – which I volition attempt to explain as conspicuously as possible! Let's outset with:

UNDER Mod PODGE

For this experiment, I applied each item to a piece of white scrapbook paper – all items were applied to the exact same type of paper, which is the blazon you can get in the scrapbooking alley at your local craft shop.

Each item was allowed to sit/dry for 20 minutes before Modern Podge was applied, even if it didn't technically need "dry fourth dimension." I also brushed over each item most 3 – 4 times with Mod Podge and a regular paint brush.

Here are the results of the smear exam. Successful means that the item didn't smear when Modern Podge was practical on the top – and I would endorse using this product with Mod Podge over the top with no hesitation. Whatever other result is explained.

PENCILS & PENS

• Colored pencils – successful
• Chalk pencils – successful
• Gel pens – successful
• Watercolor pencils – moderately successful . On virtually the 3rd or quaternary brushstroke, I started to become some smearing. This makes sense because the watercolor pencils are water activated, and Modernistic Podge is a waterbased product (so the pencils are acting as they are supposed to).
• Montana acrylic pigment pen – successful
• Faber-Castell artist pens –successful (other technical pens like Rapidograph would work every bit well)

BASICS & Art MEDIUMS

• Ballpoint pen – successful
• Lead pencil – successful
• Crayola crayons – successful
• Crayola chalk – moderately successful . Seems like some of the dust from the chalk got caught in the Mod Podge/brush and started smearing, fifty-fifty though I blew the grit away.
• Sakura Cray-Pas oil pastels – successful
• Primo charcoal sticks – unsuccessful . No surprise here. I didn't look this to piece of work since the idea of charcoal sticks is that they smear. But I wanted to run across what happened and show the results!

INK PADS

Whatever bad stamping is because of a shaky paw – please excuse. :0

• CraftSmart ink pad – unsuccessful . There'due south a smear though information technology's very slight.
• Colorbox ink pad – unsuccessful . Moderate smear.
• Encore! ink pad – unsuccessful . Major smearing!
• Memento LUXE ink pad – successful
• Ranger Archival Ink –successful
• StazOn ink pad – successful
• Tim Holtz Distress Ink –successful . (the slight bleeding on the folio is considering this is a thinner ink and information technology's interacting with the scrapbook paper, not the Mod Podge)

MARKERS

• Copic marking – successful
• Crayola markers – unsuccessful . Major smearing.
• Liquitex paint markers – successful
• Prismacolor Premier markers – successful
• Sharpie regular mark – successful
• Sharpie oil based marker –successful
• Rust-o-leum stain marker – successful
• Tombow waterbased brush pens – unsuccessful . If yous're going to Modern Podge with markers, I'd suggest sticking with some of those to a higher place that worked!

Okay, at present that we're done with that . . . permit'south move on to:

OVER Mod PODGE

For this experiment, I applied Mod Podge to the scrapbook newspaper in approximately two layers and let information technology dry for 30 minutes – an hour depending on the folio.

Basically, you would want your Mod Podge to be dry out to the touch on for this. Once the Modern Podge was dry, I applied the detail on top, And then I let that dry for twenty minutes. The final stride was to run my finger across it to see if it smeared.

Hither are the results of the smear test. Successful ways that the particular didn't smear with my finger when applied ON TOP OF Mod Podge – and I would endorse using this product on summit of Mod Podge with no hesitation. Whatever other result is explained.

PENCILS & PENS

• Colored pencils – unsuccessful . Very difficult to apply to paper, even with pressure.
• Chalk pencils – unsuccessful . Same as above.
• Gel pens – unsuccessful . Could barely meet application to page.
• Watercolor pencils – unsuccessful . Some colors worked better than others, but none were great.
• Montana acrylic paint pen – moderately successful . While the pen did utilize successfully, it was hard to fill up in areas. If you were merely writing letters, y'all'd be fine. Coloring in areas would be more difficult.
• Faber-Castell artist pens – moderately successful . While the pen did employ successfully, it was hard to make full in areas. If you were merely writing letters, you lot'd be fine. Coloring in areas would be more than difficult.

Nuts & Fine art MEDIUMS

• Ballpoint pen – moderately successful . I'd say y'all're going to need to test hither, depending on your pen. Mine worked okay, but not every stroke resulted in a line.
• Lead pencil – unsuccessful . Very difficult to write.
• Crayola crayons – successful (but yous need to push harder)
• Crayola chalk – unsuccessful . Smeared right off.
• Cray-Pas oil pastels – unsuccessful . Smeared.
• Primo charcoal sticks – unsuccessful . No surprise here – smeared.

INK PADS

• CraftSmart ink pad – unsuccessful . There's a smear though information technology's very slight.
• Colorbox ink pad – unsuccessful . Rubbed correct off easily.
• Encore! ink pad – unsuccessful . Major smearing.
• Memento LUXE ink pad – unsuccessful . Moderate smearing.
• Ranger Archival Ink – unsuccessful . Slight smearing.
• StazOn ink pad – successful
• Tim Holtz Distress Ink – unsuccessful . Definitely do your pitiful of paper before Mod Podging!

MARKERS

• Copic marker –moderately successful . A little more difficult to fill in areas completely without lines.
• Crayola markers – unsuccessful . Major smearing.
• Liquitex paint markers – moderately successful . A little more difficult to fill in areas completely without lines.
• Prismacolor Premier markers – moderately successful . A little more difficult to fill in areas completely without lines.
• Sharpie regular marker – successful
• Sharpie oil based mark –successful
• Rust-o-leum stain marker – united nations successful . Also many lines and I didn't feel similar I could color in the areas very well at all.
• Tombow waterbased brush pens – successful

So those are the results. I'd love to hear your experiences – and whatsoever questions – in the comments!

---

Besides, if you'd like to visit some related articles for decoupaging, here are some of my favorites:

• 400+ Mod Podge Craft Tutorials
• Removing Mod Podge from Surfaces
• What Exactly is Modern Podge?
• How to Transfer Photos to Wood

hanksalmosould.blogspot.com

Source: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/using-mod-podge-with-ink-markers-pencils/

Share this post